| Year |
Position |
Name |
Four-Year School |
Location |
Level |
| 2023 |
OF |
Alexis Detwiler |
Troy University |
Troy, Ala. |
NCAA Division I |
| |
P |
Kiya Hamar |
Western New Mexico University |
Silver City, N.M. |
NCAA Division II |
| |
2B |
Ella Jolley |
California State University, Fresno |
Fresno, Calif. |
NCAA Division I |
| |
SS |
Hayley Sites |
Southern Baptist University |
Bolivar, Mo. |
NCAA Division II |
| |
P/1B |
Maggie Smith |
Eastern New Mexico University |
Portales, N.M. |
NCAA Division II |
| |
C/3B |
Grace Stearns |
Southern Baptist University |
Bolivar, Mo. |
NCAA Division II |
| 2022 |
C |
Laney Berkowitz |
California State University, Chico |
Chico, Calif. |
NCAA Division II |
| |
P/1B |
Savannah Wahl |
California State University, Sacramento |
Sacramento, Calif. |
NCAA Division I |
| 2021 |
OF |
Savannah Berkowitz |
Southern Oregon University |
Ashland, Ore. |
NAIA |
| 2018 |
C |
Monica Deadmond |
Southern Oregon University |
Ashland, Ore. |
NAIA |
| |
INF |
Batlie Fryar |
Adams State University |
Alamosa, Colo. |
NCAA Division II |
| |
INF |
Camryn Mayo |
Roosevelt University |
Chicago, Ill. |
NAIA |
| |
INF |
Bailee Robicheau |
Marymount University |
Palos Verdes, Calif. |
NAIA |
| 2015 |
INF |
Taylor Peters |
University of California, Davis |
Davis, Calif. |
NCAA Division I |
| |
P |
Jessica Salsbury |
Menlo College |
Atherton, Calif. |
NAIA |
| 2014 |
C |
Halie Hall |
Culver-Stockton College |
Canton, Mo. |
NAIA |
| |
INF |
Melissa Roche |
University of Great Falls |
Great Falls, Mont. |
NAIA |
| 2013 |
INF |
Michelle Sheldon |
William Peace University |
Raleigh, N.C. |
NCAA Division III |
| 2012 |
OF |
Kaitlyn Milligan |
Menlo College |
Atherton, Calif. |
NAIA |
| 2011 |
UTL |
Annie Heskett |
University of California, San Diego |
La Jolla, Calif. |
NCAA Division I |
| |
P |
Alicia Lorenz |
Mississippi Valley State University |
Itta Bena, Miss. |
NCAA Division I |
| |
INF |
Sara Pedretti |
Menlo College |
Atherton, Calif. |
NAIA |
| 2010 |
UTL |
Sara Catania |
California State University, San Francisco |
San Francisco, Calif. |
NCAA Division II |
| 2007 |
OF |
Shelly Deadmond |
University of Oregon |
Eugene, Ore. |
NCAA Division I |